title bar - the Opera Project


PETER GRIMES

GRIMES
Peter Grimes - erratically, bewilderingly, losing his reason.
"Now the Great Bear and Pleiades
where earth moves,
are drawing up the clouds
of human grief
breathing solemnity in the deep night.

"Who can decipher
in storm or starlight
the written character
of a friendly fate -
as the sky turns the world for us to change?

"But if the horoscope's
bewildering
like a flashing turmoil
of a shoal of herring
who can turn skies back and begin again?"

 

 

 

In the tavern on a stormy night.

 

 

Ellen Orford and Peter Grimes Captain Balstrode reminds Ellen what they must do.
Captain Balstrode Ned Keane and Mrs Sedley are suspicious, while Balstrode dismisses their imaginings.

 

 

"Stand down you say, you wash your hands.
the case goes on in people's minds.
The charges that no court has made
will be shouted at my head.

"Then let me speak, let me stand trial.
Bring the accusers into the hall.
let me thrust into their mouths,
the truth itself, the simple truth.

"The truth... the pity... and the truth.
Where the walls themselves
gossip of inquest!
Until the Borough hate
poisons your mind.

"Time will not forget
the dead are witness,
and fate is blind."

Peter Grimes in the dock at his trial, Act I.

 

 

Bob Boles incites the crowd into a mob. Bob Boles and Mrs Sedley calling for Grimes to be arrested.

 

Ellen - "The Embroidery Aria" - [Nancy Gustafson]
"Embroidery in childhood was
a luxury of idleness.
A coil of silken thread giving
dreams of a silk and satin life.
Now my 'broidery affords
the clue whose meaning we avoid!

"My hand remembered its old skill -
these stitches tell a curious tale.
I remember I was brooding
on the fantasies of children...
and dreamt that ony by wishing
I could bring some silk into their lives.

"Now my 'broidery affords
the clue show meaning we avoid!"

 

 

Peter - Mad Scene 1Peter - Mad Scene 2Peter - Mad Scene 3

Peter - Mad Scene
 

"To hell with all your mercy!
To hell with your revenge.
And God have mercy upon you!

"Do you hear them all shouting my name?
D'you hear them?

"Old Davy Jones shall answer:
Come home, come home!"

 

 

TOP OF PAGE

CAPTIONS
top
The lonely fisherman, Peter Grimes, as he questions his place in the universe in the contemplative  aria "Now the Great Bear."  
In George Crabbe's narrative poem, "The Borough," published in 1810, Grimes is clearly drawn as a sadistic figure, and Benjamin Britten intended his version to be very similar. But the music makes him more complex - and more sympathetic - and subsequent generations of tenors have emphasized the poetic madness of Peter Grimes, which also changes the nature of his relationship with the townspeople. Britten reportedly loathed Jon Vickers' interpretation (the first tenor to "stray" from the composer's intent) but such is the nature of collaborative work.
[
tenor Anthony Dean Griffey]
second row
The Tavern Scene, Act I, Scene ii. Rumors and gossip are turning into suspicion, and to break up the rough mood, the landlady known as Auntie [far right] asks for help in beginning a song. Apothecary and quack Ned Keane [standing on the bench] leads the round, "Old Joe has gone fishing," with the gruff-but-kindly retired sea captain, Balstrode [front, near center] joining in. Grimes is also present and joins in the singing, but both words and tune are out of rhythm, almost of his own making, another representation of how he doesn't fit in with the villagers.

"Old Joe has gone fishing and
Young Joe has gone fishing and
You Know has gone fishing and
found them a shoal."

This is another opera where the chorus plays a major, almost a dominant role, in the opera. Many of the 19th century operas have a large chorus, but there, the role tends to be "chorus," where the group moves and reacts as one entity. In this opera, the group consists of sharply defined individuals - many with solo lines or parts in smaller ensembles as well as the entire group - and the choristers' ability to act as well as sing is quite important.

 

block - upper left
Ellen and Peter, dream about future respectability and the restoration of Peter's good name, sometimes in tandem, more often diverging. Ellen urges Peter to conform to the behavior expected by society, while Peter refuses to be anything but what he is.

[soprano Nancy Gustafson and tenor Anthony Dean Griffey]

block - upper right
Balstrode comforts Ellen as they realize that the second apprentice is missing.

"Nothing to do but wait
since the solution
is beyond life,
beyond dissolution..."

[baritone Richard Stilwell with soprano Nancy Gustafson]

 

block - lower left
Captain Balstrode discusses with Peter the borough's thoughts about the fisherman and his troubles. When he asks why Peter doesn't seek employment in the wider world, on a merchant ship, Peter replies "I'm native, rooted here." He stubbornly resists Balstrode's efforts to advise him to be more prudent in his actions, with the Captain finally crying out in frustration: "Might as well try shout the storm down, as to tell the obvious truth!"
[baritone Richard Stilwell]

block - lower right
Villagers Ned Keane and Mrs Sedley spread rumors, with Captain Balstrode facing away from them. "Now is gossip put on trial, / now the rumours either fail / or are shouted in the wind..."
[baritone John Atkins, mezzo Suzanna Guzmán, baritone Richard Stilwell]
fourth row
The opening scene, with Peter in the dock, establishes Peter's character as fighting against society. He is giving evidence at the investigation into the death of his young apprentice, a death Peter says was the result of an accident. The verdict is that the boy "died in accidental circumstances," hardly a clearing of Peter's name. The court advises him not to get another boy apprentice but to hire a man big enough to take care of himself. Peter denounces the court and the community for their verdict, which makes it impossible for him to earn a profit. The widow Ellen Orford, a friend of Peter's, says she'll help look out for the new boy.
[tenor Anthony Dean Griffey]
Peter's first entrance from the shore into the village. The rehearsal process for opera singers is different than for stage actors in the level of preparation. In the non-operatic theatre, rehearsal generally lasts from 4 to 6 weeks, and the actors learn their lines as they go through that time.

In the opera world, the singer has learned his or her role before arriving for rehearsal - in the most generous of circumstances, at least in the U.S., that might be two and a half weeks. (In Europe, sometimes the rehearsals stretch out over a longer period of time, often, anywhere, there is literally no rehearsal at all.)

Part of the difference is in the numbers of people involved to get the production to the stage, and many of those involved are union members, and time is definitely money, not to be wasted.

Philip Langridge rehearsed Peter for this particular production, and went on to sing the role throughout the run. But he was ill the couple of days surrounding the final dress rehearsal, so LA Opera had to either cancel the run-through (with an invited partial audience) or scramble to find a replacement... not an easy task, since not just everyone sings Grimes.
Tony Griffey does, though, and although quite young, had already had a great success with the role at The Met. Fortunately for LA, he was available when they called ("available" as in, in the country). He finished a rehearsal in New York, caught the red-eye to LA, survived a hotel mix-up and managed to get about 2 hours of sleep. Then he met with the wardrobe people for fittings, spent a little time with Maestro Richard Armstrong to talk about music and interpretation, and worked for a couple of hours with the assistant director, who walked Tony through the staging. As the cast started to arrive for the evening's rehearsal, they were introduced - in opera, there's usually someone you've worked with before - then the makeup people arrived to prepare Tony for the evening, and only a little jet-lagged but running on adrenalin, he went through the performance. He said afterwards there were a couple of times he couldn't remember where the exits were (stage left? upstage? up the stairs? which direction is the sea?) but his fellow cast members helped out with eye signals, and in one case, Tony - as Peter - just pretended to be confused, which worked out just fine.
fifth row - left
Bob Boles inciting the crowd:

"We'll make the murd'rer pay / we'll make him pay / for his crime!"

[tenor Greg Fedderly]

fifth row - right
The mob's cry of "Peter Grimes! Peter Grimes!" - sung unaccompanied and fortissimo - is a spine-chilling conclusion to Act III Scene i, just before they rush away to find Peter.
[tenor Greg Fedderly and mezzo Suzanna Guzmán]
 

sixth row
Ellen Orford's "Embroidery Aria" - Balstrode brings the young 'prentice's sweater to show Ellen: he's found it on the shore by Grimes' hut. Ellen recognizes it by the anchor she had embroidered there. "We have no power to help him now."
[soprano Nancy Gustafson]

end sequence
Peter's "Mad Scene" is a long, loosely-strung-together sequence of thoughts and memories, quotations from earlier sections in the opera, that don't quite make sense - and provide a clear image of one whose mind is on the verge of slipping away. Balstrode and Ellen reach Peter before the mob does, but Balstrode advises Peter to take his boat and sail until he loses sight of land, then sink the boat. Immediately following, the final short scene, reveals that life in the borough has returned to "normal."
[tenor Anthony Dean Griffey]
 
TOP OF PAGE

 

BEHIND THE SCENES

MAD SCENES IN OPERA
The mad scene in 19th century romantic-age Italian opera was created not merely to allow the heroine to express the losing of her mind in an aria of astonishingly difficult vocal pyrotechnics... but to present the disintegration of the character's mental state. Music reaches an emotional core in the listener beyond the ability of mere words to explain it, and in this way, is able to depict something as non-rational as "madness." It is the the music far more than the words that give operatic mad scenes a much greater impact than one in a play or film. Peter, separated from his mind.
Most famously in Lucia di Lammermoor, Donizetti and his near-contemporary Bellini have the highest incidence of gone-mad heroines in their various operas, after Handel and the Baroque composers (who were in the habit of writing fiendishly difficult arias and mad scenes in almost every opera). As would Gounod later, Donizetti used distorted repetitions of musical phrases from an earlier part of the opera, as if the heroine is recalling - however imperfectly - something that happened before. It is almost as if the music itself, gone haywire, is like the voice, mad in itself. Bellini, however, did not use this technique as much, nor did Verdi in his sleepwalking scene for Lady Macbeth.
But all these ladies act out erotic fantasies in their madness, an outward display of the build-up of sexual repression or trauma, pre-dating Freudian theory by several decades. Lucia's madness shows up in the novels of Tolstoy and Flaubert: "[Emma Bovary] permitted herself to be lulled by the melodies and felt her entire being stirred as if the bows of the violins were passing over her nerve-ends..."
The operas Faust, Hamlet, Macbeth and Erwartung also have soprano mad scenes, along with the bel canto Italian group, but Peter Grimes is one of the few operas with a "mad scene" for a male singer (Boris Godunov is another). Peter is losing his grip on reality rather than tapping into memories, and it is a different kind of music that expresses this. Again, though, it is the music that haunts us more than the words; the music that conveys the anguish of his madness.
 
TOP OF PAGE

 

 


Los Angeles Opera presents
PETER GRIMES by Benjamin Britten
October/November 2000

Conductor Richard Armstrong
Director John Schlesinger
Designer Luciana Arrighi
xx
Peter Grimes Anthony Dean Griffey
Ellen Orford Nancy Gustafson
Captain Balstrode Richard Stilwell
Hobson Michael Li-Paz
Auntie Judith Christin
Nieces Shana Blake Hill and Jordan Gumucio
Bob Boles Greg Fedderly
Swallow Louis Lebherz
Mrs Sedley Suzanna Guzmán
Ned Keene John Atkins
Reverend Horace Adams Jonathan Mack
Dr Crabbe Zale Kessler

 

 

EXPLORE MORE

EXPLORE

Opera Basics - An Introduction
The Opera Project - What's It All About?

Explore More: Top 10 Ways to Fall in Love With Opera

Principal Singers & Singing
Invitation to the Rehearsal Hall

WORDS & MUSIC SHOP
recommended recordings by tenors and Artist Profiles of many favorites

INDIVIDUAL OPERAS IN PHOTOGRAPHS... AND MORE

CONNECTING
e-mail ML Hart
send e-mail

PASSION & GLORY AT THE OPERA -
The Tenor Book

Just what is it about tenors, anyway? ML Hart's current project gets into the mystique.

Visit the work-in-progress for photographs/excerpts.


The Art of Making Opera
Explore more about opera and art in ML Hart's award-winning The Art of Making Opera

"The book is peppered with insightful comments..."

 

original content © copyright 2000-2005 ML Hart and images/graphics © copyright 2000-2005 ML Hart except where noted
excerpts from Peter Grimes libretto ©1945 Montagu Slater

Tim Ashley wrote a July 5, 2002 article for The Guardian entitled "Out of their minds," clarifying some of the themes present in mad scenes, principally by Bellini and Donizetti. I am indebted to this information, as some of his ideas are woven into my comments on mad scenes. -ML Hart

no part of this page, site, or any components may be borrowed, downloaded, acquired, or otherwise used by any person(s) without the express written consent of ML Hart


what is copyright all about?