TOP OF PAGE
return to ML Hart Home
title bar - The Tenor Book
a new book by ML Hart


7.  IN THE RECORDING STUDIO
Bruce Ford and
Opera Rara's recording sessions for the Rossini Otello
Henry Wood Hall - London

September / October 1999

Bruce Ford records the title role of the Rossini "Otello"

 

Bruce Ford is an American tenor of the same generation as Jerry Hadley, Richard Leech, and Neil Shicoff who makes his career primarily in Europe. Bruce is arguably (or better, inarguably) the preeminent Rossinian in the world today - along with some Donizetti, Bellini, and a whole handful of splendid roles by Mozart. I was delighted to learn he was recording the title role in Otello (the Rossini version of course) and when I was invited to photograph the recording sessions, promptly adjusted my calendar to take advantage of the opportunity. What began as a routine request for interview turned rapidly into "featured tenor," entirely because of Bruce's warmth, openness, sense of humor and approach to his work.

- ML Hart


 

THE TENOR BOOK7     FOR THE RECORD: The Rossini "Otello" for OperaRara

Bruce Ford shared star billing with another American - Elizabeth Futral as Desdemona. While there are many other musicians in this ensemble piece and many fine artists working behind the scenes to make the recording a reality, the focus here is on the tenor and his point of view.
Here are excerpts from my journals, kept during the week of recording sessions I attended in the autumn of 1999:


The hall is gorgeous - a church in its former life - rather beat up on the outside with little available parking, a serene, classical rectangle inside, restored or still in very good shape. It will be perfect for photographs, with plenty of space for me to move around, yet be out of the way. The hall turns out to be perfect acoustically, too. The entire setting and the company couldn't be better, in fact.

The studio, the command center, is a cramped, slightly-too-warm room at the back of the building: here are the monitors, the consoles, the master scores for the producer and engineers. They can see what's happening in the hall by way of an unmanned video camera, immobile at the center of the choir loft... they already have dozens of microphones in place to hear what's happening.

The first session, I've found a spot upstairs to one side of the video camera, leaning over the choir-loft rail to observe. The chorus straggles in 2 or 3 minutes before the start time; principal singers are, of course, already here, standing on risers between the orchestra and chorus; orchestra dressed even more casually than the chorus. Bruce's long-time music teacher, Mary Gillas, in town for the duration of the recording session, sits off to his side, slightly behind him. The hall is damp and chilly in the early afternoon, the weather gray and rainy outside: welcome to autumn in London...

Henry Wood Hall, London - Opera Rara recording sesison for Rossini's "Otello."
Three microphones on tall booms are arranged around the conductor's low podium, to capture the overall impact of the orchestral sound. There are microphones on very tall stands in front of each singer, at a height of 9 or 10 feet, tilted up. Microphones on stands, angled flat over the timpani, downward towards the woodwinds, up again above the French horns. A small directional microphone for the basses. More specialized microphones hang over the chorus.
Bruce Ford and Elizabeth Futral work on their duet inbetween takes.  

 

Recording sessions are an exercise in energy management. There are generally two or three rehearsals of each segment to be recorded, varying from about one minute to four or five minutes at a time. The singer must sing full out at least one of those times - though in fact, they rarely marked.

They rehearse the section again, with anywhere from 3, to 7 or 8 or more minutes inbetween - and most often the adjustments have nothing to do with the singer. He must wait and wait yet still be ready to go. He has to give a top-notch performance, balancing character interpretation, phrasing, diction, breathing and (always) musicality, just as he does onstage - and without the momentum of the live performance and audience to help carry him along.

During the inbetween parts, conductor David Parry works with his musicians or the singers on adjustments to tempi, dynamics... then he's on the phone to the producer in the studio. They play 2 more bars, and stop again.
Bruce and conductor David Parry work with the score Bruce and David Parry need to be - quite literally - on the same page
Several assistants give notes, mostly music-related, to the principals and chorus - the Italian diction coach gives a reminder to Bruce; the chorus master paces up and down in front of his singers, who are arranged in seated rows, two long rows across the back of the risers. The producer or engineer may emerge from the studio for a consultation. They've stopped again - now they're working over and over through a section of 6 or 8 bars.

 

Then the takes begin. As before, adjustments inbetween the takes and many consultations among two and three people at a time. Bruce sits, gets up, chats with the other singers, flexes his hands, swings his arms, takes off his jacket, puts on his jacket. His teacher consults with him while Maestro speaks to the first violins.

Elizabeth Futral pulls her hair into a ponytail, lets it down, goes over the score... and so they all wait in their own fashion. One of the engineers comes out to move a microphone - evidently the timpani, located next to the tenor, are too loud, obscuring Otello on his entrance.

Energy conservation - Bruce waits.
After 15 minutes of working through innumerable details in this way, the orchestra re-tunes, an announcement of the take number comes over the PA, the chorus master gets his singers up on their feet, and we're good to go.

The take ends - it was more intense, noticeably more "on" than the practicing. The singers sit or chat with each other; Maestro looks pleased. Orchestra members go back to reading magazines, maybe reviewing the next section or asking a question of Maestro.

They do three full takes of this one section, plus about 75% of it yet again, and then move on - it's done. They're rehearsing the next segment. Another thing immediately obvious about making a recording... it's like filmmaking: everything is out of sequence, depending on when the chorus is needed, which parts of the orchestra might be added for a particular scene, and whether any of the principal singers might only be available for part of the two and a half weeks scheduled for the recording.

Ever-constant note-taking...

American soprano, Elizabeth Futral, is Desdemona. Elizabeth Futral is the Desdemona, and turns out to be as friendly and warmly easy-going as Bruce. They are a good match, often working out details of difficult areas in the score together during the breaks.

In the evening session will be, all in one room, four of the six tenors in this piece - Ryland Davies, Bruce Ford, Juan José Lopera, and William Matteuzzi (the other two are Dominic Natoli and Barry Banks).

Six tenors!! Bravo Rossini! ...what a great score!

 

Bruce - determined Bruce - intense
For the Iago / Otello duet and recitative tonight, there are lots of visitors - agents, publicists, the Times music critic. Some sit in the choir loft, most remain back in the studio to observe, where the sound mix is "correct." Out in the hall, it seems completely unbalanced - you don't know which microphones are picking up what, or - significantly - at what level relative to anyone else, and you have no idea how the finished product will sound. But you get that live feeling, the electricity, aware that real people are bringing their talents and expertise together to create a whole that is greater than the sum of the parts.

The intro to the spectacularly beautiful duet (how often do we get a tenor duet?) is surprisingly difficult to get right - surprising, because it sounds as if they're just tossing off casual conversation. It's meant to sound that way. Bruce is relaxed but intensely determined. Frequently frowns and shakes his head while he's singing. Looks to be unhappy, perhaps with "space" (or lack of) from Maestro, perhaps with his own execution of the phrasing - after the second take, he leaves the room and goes back to the studio. Long pause. We all wait.

Bruce is back. Like an athlete, he stretches, flexes, bounces from one foot to the other - plants his feet wide apart when coming up on on forte passages. Singers often talk of needing a trusted set of ears to rely on - Bruce's teacher fills that role. And like a manager in the corner with a fighter, she supports and drives, offers encouragement but knows just how far to push him - and when to back off. Bruce - thoughtful
Bruce - relaxed They move to the second part of the duet. During the second - no, the third - take, someone's mobile phone rings. Clearly one of the visitors, and everyone pretends not to know who it is - a form of professional courtesy. Of course the take is ruined. Of course Bruce felt it was his best effort of the evening. He and Juan José Lopera, the tenor singing Iago, laugh about it, the laughter a little strained.

Never mind. As in the opera house on any given night, they do the best they can. A few frantic months of editing later, the recording is available in stores, coinciding with Bruce's onstage appearance at Covent Garden in the same role.

Both the recording and the production receive rave reviews (see excerpts below)... and it's on to the next city, the next opera, the next performance. This recording session, filled with tensions, long hours and ultimately, with triumphs, is just another two weeks in the life of an opera singer at the top of his game.
 

 

OPERA RARA
Patric Schmid and Bruce Ford bring Rossini's music to life.

Bruce Ford and Patric Schmid work on interpretation of a phrase.

 

 

It's immediately apparent from the relaxed atmosphere in the studio that most of these people know each other, have worked together many times before. Opera Rara is a family kind of company - I was told early on that singers who "aren't wonderful people" simply don't get hired again - and that makes for a secure environment. Everyone knows his or her role, no one has to throw their weight around in order to bolster their own confidence or impress anyone else.

This is by no means to imply that the sessions are not run in an efficient, businesslike manner. At approximately £6,000 per session, two sessions a day, time is definitely money [note: in 1999]. Nor are the singers indulged to excess - but for those who have had the experience of recording with the "major" labels, the fact that here they're treated with respect for their artistry instead of as a faceless, interchangeable commodity, is one of the things that make this company "rare," indeed.

The primary reason for all this is Artistic Director Patric Schmid, a California expatriate living in London. I asked him to tell me why. Here's his take on it:

For more about what this unique company has to offer, please visit the Opera Rara website for information, reviews, catalogue, and ordering information.
"What appeals to me initially is the thrill of discovering and preparing a piece that no living person has heard, a work that is just sitting there on a library shelf with nobody knowing what's on those pages. Trying to put the right people into the roles brings me the pleasure of dealing with the artists – just as the composers tailored their writing for the particular gifts of the different singers they worked with, for me NOTHING comes before the work of the artists in these projects. They are the ones who have to carry the work, to bring it back to life.

"So I bend over backwards to give them all the opportunities I can to somehow recreate - on their own vocal terms of course - the music in front of them. If I have anything to offer, it's a kind of vocal intuition that I tune to each singer individually in order to get the best out of them, to get them to realise the musical picture I have in my mind. They sense this and respond. This seems to produce a feeling of mutual trust – and that trust, I think, is what makes the atmosphere so wonderful in the studio.

"The atmosphere affects the orchestra and chorus as well, of course, but my main focus is always on the singers and showing them how to achieve more than they thought possible with a completely unfamiliar and untried piece of music. And although it's basically my vision of the work we're doing, it isn't a power trip... it's a collaboration."

 

 

Patric Schmid was the co-founder of Opera Rara in 1970, and for 35 years oversaw the rediscovery of dozens of neglected or forgotten works by the masters of bel canto.

Schmid combined a single-minded tenacity, with a quiet, sometimes ironic manner. He never lost the essential youthful enthusiasm which had first drawn him to his subject.

On November 6 2005, he died suddenly, having just given a pre-performance talk on the latest Donizetti rarity, Il diluvio universale (The Great Flood). The recording sessions had already taken place, and the concert, at the Theatre Royal, Drury Lane was a special occasion - the first time an opera had been heard there for decades. With the audience assembling and the orchestra warming up, he could not have planned a more fitting exit - to expire in the wings of the theatre in which Malibran had sung La sonnambula.

- Patrick O'Connor, The Guardian

 

TOP OF PAGE   |   AUTHOR'S JOURNAL   |   QUOTABLE   |    EXPLORE MORE   |   PREVIOUS    |   NEXT

 

AUTHOR'S JOURNAL     Otello, The Lion of Venice

aria1aria2aria3aria4
"What have I done!... where has a hopeless
Love led me!
I allowed it greater
Importance than glory, than my honour!"
 

 

 
RECORD OF THE WEEK   THE SUNDAY TIMES
click to go to Words&Music Shop

review by Hugh Canning
The Sunday Times
January 16, 2000

" ...the superbly athletic tenor of Bruce Ford ... reveals himself as a Rossinian without equal today; his burnished tone is not especially beautiful, but it is distinctive and his artistry puts more celebrated young tenors in the shade. He is especially moving in the final scene with Elizabeth Futral's radiant Desdemona. Opera Rara has assembled an excellent supporting cast under David Parry's idiomatic baton, with William Matteuzzi a model of style as Rodrigo and the delightful Albanian mezzo Enkelejda Shkosa a sumptuous-toned Emilia. ... "

"Bruce Ford negotiates this terrifying range [two and a half octaves -MLH] with consummate ease and minimal showiness, underpinning his vocalism with a sense of volcanic emotion."

review of Covent Garden's "Otello"   by Tim Ashley for The Guardian   February 2, 2000


As Otello at the Royal Opera House, Covent Garden, January 2000

"But the performance was dominated by the towering figure and voice of Bruce Ford, the only really possible casting for this nearly impossible role today.
...he sings throughout with a burnished, baritonal tone and quite astonishing agility, and he bestrides the stage with the nobility and authority of the
Shakespearean model. For this superlative vocal and histrionic performance, Rossini's Otello is not to be missed at Covent Garden."

review by Hugh Canning
The Sunday Times
February 6, 2000

Bruce Ford as Otello, Pesaro (photo by Amati Bacciardi)

TOP OF PAGE   |   AUTHOR'S JOURNAL   |   QUOTABLE   |    EXPLORE MORE   |   PREVIOUS    |   NEXT

 

THE INTERVIEWS - in conversation with BRUCE FORD
 

 

The interview with Bruce Ford has not yet been transcribed - but it's next on the list (May/June). When it's done, I'll include some selections here. Bruce is extremely articulate, charming, funny - a delight.

 

TOP OF PAGE   |   AUTHOR'S JOURNAL   |   QUOTABLE   |    EXPLORE MORE   |   PREVIOUS    |   NEXT

 

EXPLORE MORE


Interested in more? Just below, there's basic information about enjoying opera in general... there are photographic essays in connection with individual operas with links to stories of the operas... there are more pages in this Tenor Book section... and in Words & Music you'll find detailed profiles about many of ML Hart's favorite singers throughout history. And still more. Wander through, and enjoy.


NAVIGATION
go to Web Gallery pages
go to Jazz On Stage
go to Theatre / Dance pages
go to Opera pages
go to Papermaking pages
go to About the Artist
go to Speaking pages
go to Writings
go to Art Letter pages
go to Words & Music Shop
go to Art Links
go to Awards pages
OperaBasics - An Introduction
The Art of Making Opera - Inside the Book

Explore More: Top 10 Ways to Fall in Love With Opera

Principal Singers & Singing
Invitation to the Rehearsal Hall


INDIVIDUAL OPERAS IN PHOTOGRAPHS... AND MORE


CONNECTING
e-mail ML Hart
send e-mail

TOP OF PAGE
PRIVACY STATEMENT
ML HART HOME

WORDS & MUSIC SHOP
recommended recordings by tenors & Artist Profiles of many favorites

BRUCE FORD Profile
and recommendations for listening

coming soon: 19th CENTURY TENORS / SOPRANOS
the creators of the music that Bruce Ford often sings

 

Simply type your e-mail address in the box above and click on "subscribe."

Join the dialogue about all aspects of art.

ArtLetter
Sign up and become e-informed about ML Hart's shows, projects & publications, appearances and more... and all the updates about PASSION & GLORY AT THE OPERA - The Tenor Book

 
"This is the ideal book for everyone who loves opera."

ORDER "The Art of Making Opera"

"... a distinguished book with heart."

THE ART OF MAKING OPERA

Your invitation backstage to learn how opera - and art - is made.
THE ART OF MAKING OPERA garnered international praise and won awards. Get a glimpse of what's inside. Or get your own copy - click on the book cover at left for a special offer on orders placed through this website. 

The OperaWest critic says:
"Hart's observations about what goes on backstage, frontstage and all around the theatre are - I can only say - truly revelatory. This is one of the best books I've ever read on the creation of opera."



AT THE OPERA  |  JAZZ ON STAGE  |  THEATRE & DANCE
ABOUT THE ARTIST  |  PAPERMAKING  |  WEB GALLERY
ART LINKS  |  NEWSLETTER  |  WORDS & MUSIC SHOP



original content © copyright 1999-2006 ML Hart and images/graphics © copyright 1999 ML Hart
except where noted
excerpts from book reviews can be found in context here

Bruce Ford as Otello, Pesaro: photo by Amati Bacciardi

excerpts from Patric Schmid obituary in The Guardian, November 16, 2005
by Patrick O'Connor

exclusive excerpts from ML Hart's interviews with:
Patric Schmid - November 1999
Bruce Ford - September 30, 1999

no part of this page, site, or any components may be borrowed, downloaded, acquired, or otherwise used by any person(s) without the express written consent of ML Hart
- all rights reserved -


what is copyright all about?